Back to the blog

Google AI Overviews and AI Mode: how many clicks you lose and what to do now

3D illustration: a floating crystal bundles beams of light into an answer orb while only a few boats still sail; Imp guides one boat with a lantern towards a jetty with a shopping basket.

Your rankings are holding, impressions are climbing, and clicks keep falling. That is the exact pattern Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode produce: in Seer Interactive's analysis, organic CTR on queries with an AI Overview dropped from 1.76% to 0.61%. So how many clicks do AI Overviews really cost you, and what does that mean for content and budget? If you only watch traffic, you will draw the wrong conclusions.

Google AI Overviews and AI Mode cost clicks mainly on informational queries: studies measure roughly 40% to more than 60% fewer organic clicks, paid CTR drops too, while impressions often rise. Clicks survive where users want to act: comparisons, pricing, tools and original data. Measure the effect separately for brand, non-brand and intent, plan with realistic CTRs instead of old benchmarks, and move content and paid budget towards high-intent queries.

How many clicks do AI Overviews and AI Mode really cost?

Seer Interactive analysed 3,119 informational queries across 42 organisations between June 2024 and September 2025. On queries with an AI Overview, organic CTR fell from 1.76% to 0.61% and paid CTR from 19.7% to 6.34%. Even queries without an AI Overview only reached 1.62% organic CTR. In other words, click-through rates are not just shrinking where the AI box shows up.

The cleanest evidence of cause and effect so far comes from a randomised field experiment by Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen with more than 1,000 US users. One group had the AI Overview hidden via a browser extension, and the researchers compared its click behaviour with a control group. The result: with an AI Overview there were about 39.8% fewer organic clicks, and the probability of a search ending without any click rose by roughly a third. Satisfaction with the search was almost identical in both groups.

Pew Research confirms the pattern from the user side: when an AI summary appeared, users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, compared with 15% without one. The basis was browsing data from 900 US adults in March 2025. According to SparkToro, 68.01% of Google searches in the US between January and April 2026 ended without a click.

There is an important counterpoint. Brands cited inside an AI Overview received 35% more organic clicks and 91% more paid clicks than brands that were not cited, according to Seer. Being cited is a click driver in its own right. How to work on that deliberately is covered in our guide to GEO and AEO for AI recommendations, and the technical groundwork in the piece on llms.txt, schema.org and entities.

Where are B2B, SaaS and e-commerce hit hardest?

BrightEdge looked at the first year of AI Overviews: search impressions rose by more than 49%, while clicks fell by almost 30%. According to BrightEdge, B2B tech is among the industries with the strongest AI Overview presence, whereas the share in e-commerce barely grew. For SaaS vendors and B2B service firms, educational "how to" traffic is therefore the most exposed asset. For online shops, it is mostly buying-guide content.

AI Mode sharpens the pattern. People ask longer questions there and follow up with more questions instead of clicking through to results. For you, that means impressions on lots of long-tail queries with very few clicks attached.

How do you measure the impact in Search Console and GA4?

The core symptom is a widening gap: impressions up, CTR down, position stable. Two details matter when you read the data. Search Console counts clicks on external links inside AI Overviews as regular clicks, and all links in one AI Overview share the same position. There is no separate click metric for AI Overviews.

Since 31 August 2026, every website worldwide also has access to the "Generative AI performance" report. It shows how often links to your site were displayed in AI Overviews and AI Mode, broken down by page, country, device and date. It does not show clicks or queries. If your performance report is already playing up, our article on delayed Search Console data in reporting helps.

A five-step measurement plan

  1. Separate brand from non-brand. Add a regex filter for your brand terms in the performance report. The AI effect shows up mainly in the non-brand segment.
  2. Cluster by intent. Split non-brand queries into informational (how, what, why) and commercial (comparison, pricing, vendor, alternative). Compare CTR per cluster over twelve months.
  3. Flag the AI-exposed pages. Export the pages with the most impressions from the Generative AI report and match them against the pages whose CTR has fallen the most. The overlap is your priority list.
  4. Make AI referrals visible in GA4. Create a custom channel group whose source matches a regex with terms like chatgpt, openai, perplexity, gemini or copilot, and place that channel above "Referral". Keep the regex tight, or unrelated sources end up in your AI channel. Traffic from AI Overviews stays inside organic Google traffic.
  5. Judge by pipeline, not sessions. Connect organic search leads to your CRM data. Fewer clicks with the same number of leads is not a problem. The foundation for this is a clean tracking and analytics setup.

Scenario maths with the click formula

The basic formula is expected clicks = impressions × CTR, and from there leads = clicks × conversion rate.

Assume a SaaS company has 40,000 monthly non-brand impressions on informational guide pages and a lead conversion rate of 2%. At a CTR of 1.76%, that gives 704 clicks and roughly 14 leads. At 0.61%, it is 244 clicks and roughly 5 leads. Even if impressions rise by 20% to 48,000 at the same time, you only get 293 clicks and roughly 6 leads. In this example, more visibility does not make up for the CTR loss.

Run the same calculation with your own numbers for each cluster. If the lead loss on guide pages is smaller than what an additional high-intent page can deliver, the case for shifting effort is clear. If it is larger, work on citability and snippets first.

Which content still earns clicks?

Clicks happen when people want to do, check or calculate something:

  • Bottom-of-funnel pages: pricing, vendor selection, alternatives pages, integrations, implementation effort.
  • Comparisons with a transparent method: evaluation criteria and honest pros and cons, including for your own product.
  • Tools and calculators: ROI calculators, configurators, downloadable checklists.
  • Original data: benchmarks, surveys and analyses from your market. Whoever owns the primary source gets cited.

Definition and how-to articles still matter as feeders: they build topical authority, get cited in AI answers and link through to high-intent pages. How to plan that mix is part of our SEO services.

Content and budget strategy: how do you rebalance SEO and paid?

Paid is not an automatic replacement, because paid CTR drops on AI Overview queries as well. According to Google Ads Help, ads inside AI Overviews only run in English in selected markets such as the US, Canada, Australia and India; the DACH region is not included. Ads above and below AI Overviews can appear in every market where AI Overviews exist. There is no opt-out, and no dedicated reporting for ads in AI Overviews either.

Google also expanded ads in AI Mode to ten more markets at the end of October 2026, including Canada, Australia and India. The UK, Brazil and Mexico are due to follow in the fourth quarter; no EU country is on the list. There is no separate campaign type: existing Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns are eligible automatically. How much inventory that is shows up in an SE Ranking analysis of 50,032 commercial US keywords from June 2026: a text ad appeared in AI Mode for 29.45% of them. If you advertise in those markets, this is already your reality; if you advertise in Germany, Austria or Switzerland, it is the preview you should prepare your account structure for now.

Three rules for the mix:

  1. Don't buy back informational keywords with paid. Paid CTR falls there too. Budget belongs on commercial and brand-adjacent queries.
  2. Test broad match and AI Max deliberately, with clear brand controls, URL exclusions and conversion goals based on CRM data. That way you are ready when AI Mode ads reach your markets.
  3. Reallocate SEO budget: less volume of generic guides, more bottom-of-funnel pages, data projects and tools. Evaluate by leads per page, not by sessions.

FAQ

Can I see clicks from AI Overviews separately in Search Console?

No. Those clicks sit inside the regular performance report, and the Generative AI report only shows impressions by page, country, device and date. You infer the impact from CTR changes per page and per intent cluster.

Do ads already run inside AI Overviews or AI Mode in Germany?

Not inside AI Overviews or AI Mode at the moment. According to Google, ads in AI Overviews are so far limited to English in selected markets, and ads in AI Mode are limited to selected markets too, neither of which includes the DACH region. Your ads can, however, appear above and below AI Overviews.

Is the click loss from AI Overviews proven or just a correlation?

It is proven. Alongside observational studies such as Seer, Pew and BrightEdge, there is a randomised field experiment in which hiding the AI Overview measurably increased clicks. The size of the effect varies by method; the direction is unambiguous.

Sources

Want more of the attention you get to turn into customers? Let’s spend 15 minutes on your setup, free and without a pitch deck. Book your free call

Keep reading

Let’s take a look.

15 minutes, free, no pitch deck. We look at your setup and tell you honestly where the biggest potential is.

Book a free callFree checkPrefer talking? Call us or send a WhatsApp. +49 163 1695917 · WhatsAppor email us at hello@wiro.design
Free check